Published in Blog

Ireland's decline to Tier 2 Watch List

Written by  Sunday, 23 May 2021 14:16 Be the first to comment!
Ireland Tier Ranking By Year. Source: 2020 Trafficking in Persons Report. Ireland Tier Ranking By Year. Source: 2020 Trafficking in Persons Report.

 

With the launch of the Trafficking In Persons Report 2021 imminent, Ireland's government will be anxiously awaiting the news of how the country has fared under international scrutiny. Yearly, the U.S. State Department assesses the performance of countries around the work and allocates a tier ranking. Presently Ireland finds itself ranked as a Tier 2 Watch List country alongside others such as Chad, Pakistan, Mali, Uganda, Sudan, Vietnam and Saudi Arabia. Below these Tier 2 Watch List countries are only 22 others. It is ignominious ranking for Ireland a country that, only years before, occupied a Tier 1 ranking. The situation is made worse when one considers Ireland's international standing: Ireland is presently a member of the UN Security Council and it is the only European Union country to occupy such a low tier. Ireland enjoys the advantage of being economically prosperous, something that cannot be said about many of the countries that have the same Tier 2 Watch List ranking.

The decline in Ireland's ranking is not new.The problems first became apparent in 2018 when the country lost Tier 1 ranking to fall to Tier 2. In 2019, Ireland maintained this ranking. However, in the Trafficking in Persons Report 2020 Ireland's ranking slipped again and the country found itself in the hazardous waters of Tier 2 Watch List. The report describes Tier 1 as the ranking attained by countries whose governments fully meet with the minimum standards of the United States' TVPA (Trafficking Victims Protection Act). Tier 2 counties are those whose governments do not fully comply with the minimum standards, but it is nonetheless recognised that significant efforts are being made to attain them. Below this is the Tier 2 Watch List ranking. This tier is allocated when countries do not meet the requirements of the TVPA, despite significant efforts, and there are further issues. These issues are:

  • "the estimated number of victims of severe forms of trafficking is very significant or is significantly increasing and the country is not taking proportional concrete actions;"
  • "there is a failure to provide evidence of increasing efforts to combat severe forms of trafficking in persons from the previous year, including increased investigations, prosecution, and convictions of trafficking crimes, increased assistance to victims, and decreasing evidence of complicity in severe forms of trafficking by government officials." 

In the Trafficking in Persons Report 2020 Ireland's attempts to comply with the minimum standards was duly noted. However, this was balanced against other considerations. In the assessment of the U.S. State Department, increased efforts had not been made when compared with the previous year. Additionally, deterrence had been weakened by the failure to obtain a human trafficking conviction since a 2013 change in legislation. This, it was assessed, "contributed to impunity for traffickers, and undermined efforts to support victims to testify". As if this wasn't bad enough, additional problems were identified including ones associated with assisting identified victims of human trafficking.

Read 78 times Last modified on Sunday, 23 May 2021 15:18

Got something to say? Go for it!

Make sure you enter all the required information, indicated by an asterisk (*). HTML code is not allowed.


 
 

Open Secrets: An Irish Perspective on Trafficking and Witchcraft

Open Secrets: An Irish Perspective on Trafficking and Witchcraft explores modern slavery, human trafficking, and their slaves, all from the perspective of present-day events in Ireland.

Happening Now

'It's nice to bring somebody into the world': Coventry firefighters deliver baby boy in back...

6 Cranston massage parlors shuttered amid human trafficking investigation · 12 NEWS NOW: RI COVID-19 data for Friday, June 18.

VB Restaurant Association says plan for crowds Father's Day weekend

Norfolk Public Library employees certified to recognize human trafficking. Video ... VB hotel association says to plan early when booking reservations.

Pornhub profits from rape, child pornography and sex trafficking, dozens of women allege in lawsuit

Nearly three dozen women sued Pornhub on Thursday, alleging that the firm operates as a “classic criminal enterprise” that profits from content ...

List of angry local swimming pool company customers is growing

Following WAVY Investigator Chris Horne's report into Artistic Pools and ... Norfolk Public Library employees certified to recognize human trafficking.

Immigration Weekly Round-Up: Attorney General Expands Eligibility for Asylum; Employment to Be ...

... victims of significant crimes – such as domestic violence, human trafficking, rape, and aggravated assault – and subsequently, aid the police and/or ...

4 Rohingya men arrested over human trafficking: UP ATS

Police alleged that the arrested persons were running a human trafficking syndicate and were involved in preparing forged government documents. By: ...

Drug trafficker caught in Sudbury sent to pen

Back on March 24 of 2020, Earle – who was charged in August 2019 as part of Project Skylark – pleaded guilty to methamphetamine trafficking, ...

Bonta launches human trafficking, sexual predator apprehension teams

"Plain and simple, human trafficking is a modern-day form of slavery," Bonta said. "Whether it's forced labor or commercial sexual exploitation of ...

How Europe deals with the new wave of refugees is a test of our humanity

All of them had spent years in Libya, trapped between smugglers and government-aligned detention centres, while facing starvation, extortion, forced ...

13 arrested in undercover human trafficking operation in Flagler County

The Special Investigations Unit teamed up with Homeland Security Investigations for a two-day operation to help identify and combat human trafficking in ...

Pornhub sued by dozens of women alleging it profits from non-consensual content

MindGeek, the owner of PornHub, has created a “bustling marketplace” for “child pornography, rape videos, trafficked videos and every other form of ...

Norfolk Public Library employees certified to recognize human trafficking

In Norfolk, employees are taking that a step further by making sure they know the signs of human trafficking. It's a quiet place that doubles...

Celebrities Back $30M Budget Ask As State Steps Up Enforcement Against Human Trafficking

The Human Trafficking and Sexual Predator Apprehension Teams – established last year with one each in Southern California and Northern ...

California boosts anti-human trafficking teams

The California attorney general launched new anti-human trafficking teams to apprehend perpetrators and support survivors on Friday amid an ...

Issue of human trafficking taking focus with signing of bill

Governor John Bel Edwards signed into law the creation of the Office of Human Trafficking Prevention. AddThis Sharing Buttons. Share to Facebook ...

Columbus deputy chief rappels down Chase Tower to help victims of child sex trafficking

COLUMBUS, Ohio (WSYX) — Columbus Police Deputy Chief Jennifer Knight is taking the fight against human trafficking to new heights.

6 Cranston massage parlors shuttered amid human trafficking investigation

“Our residents deserve to live in a peaceful and safe community, and we take all quality life issues seriously,” Winquist said. “I thank the many...

Office of Human Trafficking Prevention looks to help more survivors

It aims to tackle the underground issue that affects all corners of the state. Human trafficking in Louisiana is not just in Baton Rouge or...

Supreme Court Narrows Alien Tort Statute Liability

Plaintiffs in Nestlé and Cargill are Malian citizens who allege that they were trafficked into the Ivory Coast and forced to work on cocoa farms...

Juneteenth: Closing a 'damaging slavery loophole'

We are grateful to Senator Merkley and Representative Williams for taking this step toward ending forced labor and labor trafficking in the U.S. prison ...

SCOTUS Rules in Favor of Nestlé & Cargill in Child Slave Labor Case

The men were trafficked from Mali as children and forced to work on cocoa plantations in the Ivory Coast which supplied the U.S. companies.

SIA sees trust in supporting role for avoiding biometric moratorium

It has exonerated innocent people accused of crimes, helped with terrorism investigations and saved victims of human trafficking. Of course, it has also ...

Attorney General Bonta Formally Launches New Regional Human Trafficking and Sexual Predator ...

“Plain and simple: Human trafficking is a modern-day form of slavery. Whether it's forced labor or commercial sexual exploitation of children, there is ...

More Than 30 Women Sue Pornhub, Accusing Site Of Profiting Off Human Trafficking, Sexual ...

The website Pornhub is accused in a civil lawsuit of violating federal sex trafficking laws by profiting off the spread of child pornography, rape revenge ...

Joe Biden: Soft on Slavery

“Human traffickers (as opposed to smugglers) lure unsuspecting migrants with promises of all sorts of opportunity in the U.S., and then hold them ...

Revealed: British police received further complaint of sex crimes in relation to Jeffrey Epstein in...

In May 2015, the MPS was contacted by representatives of a person who made allegations of non-recent trafficking for sexual exploitation against a US ...

Taiwan Under Fire for Racist Policies Toward Southeast Asian Workers

Migrant workers at several Taiwanese factories say they are being denied ... migrant workers at Taiwan's ASE semiconductor manufacturer are being forced ... The United...

Cranston Police Shut Down Suspected Illegal Massage Parlors

... suspicious activity at six massage businesses in Cranston has resulted in 11 arrests and uncovered evidence of human trafficking and prostitution.

Nestle Ruling Shows Supply Chain Human Rights Flaws

Doe allege that they are former slaves, kidnapped from Mali as children and trafficked to the Ivory Coast, where they were sold and forced to...

California launches new anti-human trafficking teams

LOS ANGELES (AP) — The California attorney general launched new anti-human trafficking teams to apprehend perpetrators and support survivors ...

Uttar Pradesh police arrests 4 Rohingyas involved in human trafficking

According to the police, the gang was involved in preparing forged voter cards, Aadhaar cards and passports besides human trafficking. The accused ...

Pennsylvania Approves Bill to Protect Trafficking Victims | News

Trafficking refers to recruiting, transporting, moving, detaining, or receiving people by force, fraud, or fraud for forced labor or sexual exploitation.

Judge Nixes Staffing Firm's Request to Dismiss Trafficking Case

A federal judge in Ohio denied a health-care staffing company's bid to dismiss human trafficking charges against it leveled by a former employee.

Studio 6a raising awareness for human trafficking with 'Change a Life Cut-A-Thon Summer Festival'

"Tp, xf ibwf efdjefe up qbsuofs xjui uifn up ep uijt gvoesbjtfs.” Tfwfsbm nfbojohgvm npnfout gspn uif boovbm hbmb xjmm cf jodmvefe jo uif gftujwbm,...

Department of Justice Wins Conviction in Billings Human Trafficking Case

BILLINGS – A New Mexico man was convicted of aggravated promotion of prostitution Wednesday in Yellowstone County District Court following an ...

Pornhub faces lawsuit for allegedly participating in child porn, rape, human trafficking

NEW YORK, N.Y. (CBS NEWS) - Pornhub is facing a lawsuit from over for being complicit when videos of child porn, rape and human trafficking...

Teams That Busted Chesco Human Trafficking Ring Awarded

EAST WHITELAND TOWNSHIP, PA — Law enforcement teams that worked together to dismantle a ring of sex traffickers in Chester County last ...

Rhode Island police shut down suspected illegal massage parlors

... activity at six massage businesses in Cranston has resulted in 11 arrests and uncovered evidence of human trafficking and prostitution, police Col.

2 sentenced over false documents in human trafficking

A divorced Georgian couple who lived together in Dublin facilitated human trafficking by acting as a "distribution network" and providing people with ...

Accused in Pori Moni attempted rape-murder case, Omi faces human trafficking charges

Tuhin Siddique Omi, accused in an attempted rape and murder case started by actress Pori Moni, has also been charged with human trafficking in ...

About David Lohan

David Lohan is an author and researcher on modern slavery, a phenomenon otherwise known as human trafficking. He first encountered the issue of modern slavery during his work with an organization providing outreach to refugees and asylum seekers. His first book on the subject, a co-authored work, explored the role played by African witchcraft in present-day slavery. He holds a bachelor's degree in engineering and several post-graduate qualifications. His Master of Art (Politics) research explored policy approaches aimed at combating slavery. He is presently working on his second book on modern slavery.

With a commitment to victims of modern slavery.

© Copyright 2016 by DavidLohan.com. All Rights Reserved.

Back to the top.