Published in Blog

What is the Trafficking in Persons Report?

Written by  Tuesday, 07 March 2017 18:36 Be the first to comment!
Image from the U.S. Department of State. Image from the U.S. Department of State.

The Trafficking in Persons Report, sometimes simply known as the TIP Report, is a fascinating document. At first glance it is merely a governmental report. In practise it is much more. It goes far beyond the limitations of most other such reports. The purpose of this report is not to catalogue the human trafficking in each of the world's states, a task its authors nonetheless achieve admirably, but rather to influence the world's countries to do something about their human trafficking situation. The U.S. Department of State acknowledges this is so when it declares it to be a tool. "The Trafficking in Persons (TIP) Report is the U.S. Government’s principal diplomatic tool to engage foreign governments on human trafficking", it discloses. What then is this Trafficking in Persons Report?

What is the Trafficking in Persons Report?

The report has its origins in the Victims of Trafficking and Violence Protection Act of 2000. This law is sometimes more loosely referred to as the Trafficking Victims Protection Act or the TVPA. It requires the publication of a report outlining the "description of  the  nature  and  extent  of  severe  forms of  trafficking  in  persons ...  in  each  foreign  country." (Nowadays the United States is also scrutinised in the report). It also describes a framework for assessing the situation. The law compels the report's authors to consider whether, for example, "government  authorities ... participate in, facilitate, or condone such trafficking" and to consider too the steps each government has taken to prohibit individuals "from participating in such trafficking, including the investigation, prosecution, and conviction of individuals involved." Among the measures of the law's framework are ones aimed at protecting victims of human trafficking. To this end the TVPA requires the report to consider the steps being taken by each country to assist victims and to prevent these victims from further exploitation. It also mandates that victimhood be recognised by governments and that victims be protected from the possibility of being wrongly prosecuted.

The report is authored by personnel of the Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons (J/TIP), an agency within the U.S. Department of State, and it is published annually, usually in June, by the department. Going through the report one gets a sense of the enormity of the undertaking needed to make its publication possible. Before any of this work can commence the department issues, using its global network of embassies, a series of invitations to partners around the world to make submissions on the contemporary situation in their area. These submissions are then collated and analysed. The results of this process play a role in informing the final narrative.

The publication is a significant milestone in the calendar of the department, one that is marked by a public launch. The presence of the Secretary of State at successive launches underlines the importance of the issue of human trafficking to recent U.S. administrations. It also serves to draw the attention of the world's media to the issue and to promote the matter abroad.

 


Credit: U.S. Department of State
Source:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=viw-eBxl0PQ

The situation in each country is described in meticulous detail using country-specific narratives. There is a science behind how the report's authors construct these narratives. They begin by providing information on the profile of the human trafficking situation in the country over the past few years. They then provide a summary of government efforts to combat human trafficking, before making recommendations on how the country's government can improve upon those efforts. Thereafter the narratives address measures in terms of a 3P paradigm: prosecution, protection, and prevention. There is one other element, a very important one, to these narratives and it sits right at their beginning. The country-specific narrative discloses the score awarded to the country for the past year's performance.

 Source: Trafficking in Persons Report 2016, p.64.

Section 108 of the TVPA establishes yet another framework, this time in the form of a set of minimum standards. These minimum standards are ones it asserts are needed for a country to be on the right path towards eliminating human trafficking. The Department of State uses these minimum standards to allocate the scoring, in the form of a tier ranking, to countries annually. While a country can achieve the top Tier 1 ranking one year it might achieve a lower ranking the next. This is potentially a source of embarrassment for governments, one which may highlight systematic failure to tackle the issue. It is also problematic for persistently poor performers as it carries with it the risk of international financial aid to the country being withdrawn.

The TVPA has been amended several times since it was first introduced in 2000. One important thing to note that the tiers do not describe the trafficking situation in a country, but rather the conformance of that country to the minimum standards. The Department of State says: "While Tier 1 is the highest ranking, it does not mean that a country has no human trafficking problem. On the contrary, a Tier 1 ranking indicates that a government has acknowledged the existence of human trafficking, made efforts to address the problem, and complies with the TVPA’s minimum standards." There is no room for complacency then. Even when a country has scored highly one year there is no guarantee it will be scored as highly the next year. In this way the system of ranking countries, and renewing those rankings annually, serves to encourage those who have not done well one year to improve the next, and to encourage those who have performed well not to slip down the rankings.

Where to find the Trafficking in Persons Report.

Credit: U.S. Department of State

The current edition of the Trafficking in Persons Report and earlier versions are available from the section addressing human trafficking on the U.S. Department of State's website. You can find that section here.

 

Read 1721 times Last modified on Thursday, 16 March 2017 18:01
More in this category: « Beyond slavery's facade

Got something to say? Go for it!

Make sure you enter all the required information, indicated by an asterisk (*). HTML code is not allowed.


 
 

Open Secrets: An Irish Perspective on Trafficking and Witchcraft

Open Secrets: An Irish Perspective on Trafficking and Witchcraft explores modern slavery, human trafficking, and their slaves, all from the perspective of present-day events in Ireland.

Happening Now

IHREC becomes Ireland's National Rapporteur on Human Trafficking

The role will include carrying out of assessments of trends in trafficking in human beings, the measuring of results of anti-trafficking actions, including the ...

Nonprofit takes stand against sex trafficking

In 2012, Schlabach launched nonprofit Zoë Ministries to help people recognize, report and combat sex trafficking, and to provide long-term treatment to ...

S. Dennis Man Indicted for Sex Assault on Minor, Other Charges

First-degree human trafficking carries a sentence of 20 years without parole to life in state prison. Ross was arrested by the New Jersey State Police ...

More than 90 anti-trafficking organizations are denouncing QAnon in an open letter

The letter, signed by groups including Freedom Network USA, Alliance to End Slavery and Trafficking, the Human Trafficking Institute, and more, say ...

Novel highlights Midwest human trafficking

Erickson lives in Sioux Falls, South Dakota. Police and anti-human trafficking activists are beset with a slate of trafficking victims who find themselves ...

Uttar Pradesh: Anti-Human Trafficking Units To Be Set Up In 40 More Districts

The Uttar Pradesh government will set up Anti-Human Trafficking Units (AHTU) in 40 districts of the state. It will enable these units to register FIRs...

Why Yorkshire human trafficking survivor's dream of becoming a nurse needs a fundraising page

A crowdfunder has raised thousands of pounds to help a human trafficking survivor living in Yorkshire pursue her dream of qualifying as a nurse.

Latvian aviation industry agrees joint effort to prevent human trafficking

Laila Odiņa, chairperson of the board of Riga Airport, commented, “Human trafficking is one of the most serious crimes, a gross violation of human ...

Emirates help shine a spotlight on the issue of human trafficking

Emirates is proud to support It's a Penalty's campaign's newest global film “What is Human Trafficking?” launched in collaboration with actor Liam ...

Kidnapping and trafficking cases on the rise in SA

A NGOs involved in assisting victims of kidnapping and trafficking say Covid-19 has created the perfect environment for these crimes to thrive, and ...

Sex trafficking victim's story to highlight Shine the Light campaign

More. The owner of a spa in Lambeth, who was a victim of sex trafficking, is being spotlighted as part of this ...

Photoshoot takes place for human trafficking awareness

Nikki Burger from Corning, N.Y., held a photo shoot to raise awareness about human trafficking. The event, #SaveOurChildren, was for women, men, ...

DHS opens Center for Countering Human Trafficking

“Human trafficking is modern-day slavery. There is no other way to say it,” Acting DHS Secretary Chad Wolf said. “The words are strong because the ...

Women's Center, GLOW Sculpting Spa offer free tattoo removal for domestic violence, human ...

(WJMN) – Experiencing domestic violence and human trafficking can not only permanently scar a person emotionally, but also physically on the body.

Statement on the Detention of Kamchy Kolbaev

Kolbaev's criminal network is based in Central Asia and is involved in drug trafficking, arms trafficking, human trafficking, extortion, and other crimes.

Human Trafficking Survivor Harold D'Souza: “The Perpetrators are More Aggressive Than Ever”

He and his wife were forced to work in a restaurant seven days a week for as long as 16 hours a day. His employer...

TKXToday.com : Woman loses appeal in sex trafficking case

A Texas appeals court has upheld the life sentence of a woman convicted of human trafficking in Bowie County earlier this year. Linda “Gucci” Dooley ...

Human trafficking survivor teaches kids, adults how to be safer online during COVID-19

Timea Nagy of Cambridge, Ont., says COVID-19 has increased the activity and access of human traffickers because of all the time young people are ...

First Memorial To Survivors Of Sex Trafficking To Be Unveiled At Lykins Square Park In...

One of four glass panels Hasna Sal created to tell the story of sex trafficking victims. McDonald's life in prostitution, which she's written a book...

New Friends New Life Announces Sold: Conference on Human Trafficking and Exploitation

Founded in Dallas, Texas in 1998, New Friends New Life (NFNL) restores and empowers formerly trafficked and sexually exploited women, teen girls ...

Britain is failing to protect child victims of human trafficking

Trafficked children face a hostile immigration system in Britain with very few being granted leave to remain. Patricia Durr is the Chief Executive of ECPAT ...

Human trafficking: Tripura police rescue two girls

The rescued girls were being taken to Bangalore when they were rescued. Police said that the duo was lured with a better job and secured...

Ivanka Trump talks sex trafficking, school choice at Fort Myers rally

The first daughter and the president's advisor spoke first to a crowd of about 400 and then talked exclusively with NBC2. Below is a partial...

Two people behind bars after sex trafficking bust in Oklahoma City

OKLAHOMA CITY (KFOR) – Two people have been booked into the Oklahoma County Detention Center in recent weeks after a sex trafficking bust in ...

Virtual forum tackling human trafficking in Middle East concludes

Dr. Anwar bin Mohammed Gargash, Minister of State for Foreign Affairs and Chairman of the National Committee to Combat Human Trafficking, opened ...

Pontiac man bound over in case involving sex trafficking of college women

... 52-3 District Court Judge Lisa Asadoorian on multiple felony counts, including forced labor/commercial sex and conducting a criminal enterprise.

77% of children who migrate to the Mediterranean suffer abuse

The trafficking of minors – which includes forced labor, sexual exploitation, violence, child marriage or illicit retention – is a practice that alone between ...

Judge dismisses extortion counts in Luz del Mundo sex abuse case

... other high-ranking church members, seeking damages for human trafficking, racketeering, sexual battery and forced labor, among other charges.

Newsom to be sued over fracking permits

Of those, 78% were trafficked for sex and 22% for forced labor. ... Labor trafficking appears to be concentrated in the Central Valley. Although Fresno ...

India sees increase in child trafficking amid pandemic

Since the Covid-19 pandemic began, India has seen an increase in child trafficking and forced labor as a result of economic loss of poor families.

Gov. Newsom expected to be sued after issuing new fracking permits

Of those, 78% were trafficked for sex and 22% for forced labor. ... and empowering additional state agencies to investigate labor trafficking crimes.

California judge tosses extortion charges against megachurch leader; child rape and human ...

California judge tosses extortion charges against megachurch leader; child rape and human trafficking counts left in place ...

Atlantic City Casino Sting: Two Men, One Woman Indicted Over Sex Plot Involving 14-Year-Old Girl

The pair accused of human trafficking could spend up to life in prison if convicted, given the many charges. All three defendants are from New...

Australian think tank ASPI found linked to prison labor, human trafficking

ASPI previously released a report on China's Xinjiang, claiming that at least 80,000 Uygurs were "forced" to work in factories in Xinjiang and other ...

Vatican Roundup

Pandemic 'increases risks of human trafficking'. While the Covid-19 pandemic has shut down or slowed most businesses, it does not appear to have put ...

DHS Launches Center to 'Combat and Dismantle' Human Trafficking

Forced labor and human trafficking is estimated to be a $150 billion industry worldwide, according to the U.N.'s International Labour Organization.

Forget the soaring rhetoric, the details of law are what will advance slavery eradication

In the week of the UK's Anti-Slavery Day, and the EU's Anti-Trafficking Day, (both 18th Oct) it is nice to see the range of virtual...

Where are they now? All the major players in NXIVM, an alleged sex cult covered...

Raniere was convicted of sex trafficking of children, conspiracy, and conspiracy to commit forced labor in June 2019. He faces a lifetime sentence, ...

OPINION: Lose the rhetoric and look to the law to end modern slavery

Governments prefer voluntary initiatives to legally binding systems that could help tackle trafficking and slavery. Aidan McQuade is an expert on ...

Fincher Studies Labor Trafficking, Domestic Violence

Hernandez said victims of labor trafficking often are forced to work excessively long hours while their wages are controlled by their abusers. They often ...

About David Lohan

David Lohan is an author and researcher on modern slavery, a phenomenon otherwise known as human trafficking. He first encountered the issue of modern slavery during his work with an organization providing outreach to refugees and asylum seekers. His first book on the subject, a co-authored work, explored the role played by African witchcraft in present-day slavery. He holds a bachelor's degree in engineering and several post-graduate qualifications. His Master of Art (Politics) research explored policy approaches aimed at combating slavery. He is presently working on his second book on modern slavery.

With a commitment to victims of modern slavery.

© Copyright 2016 by DavidLohan.com. All Rights Reserved.

Back to the top.